While the Transhuman National Committee (TNC) has been working on the formation and legal structures to provide the TNC with the legal foundation for moving forward as well as the policy and platform development the board has done some research beyond that scope around the current election.
It is the TNC Board opinion that the current state of the election process and the candidates currently in the front running are indicative to the poor state of the American political process. In terms of coalition size the democratic process has been severely undermined creating effectively smaller coalitions and opening the doors to wide spread corruption. Cases in point include gerrymandering (manipulating congressional districts), the electoral college, the use of voting blocks and pork barrel spending. Setting these issues aside, the TNC executive committee believes these are related fact’s that members of the TNC should be aware of.
- On a scale of a possible 90 points (10 for each TNC Policy platform choice) the current front runner candidates as well as two others include the following scores:
- Trump (R) 2 points of a possible 90.
- Clinton (D) 6 points of a possible 90.
- Johnson (L) 4 points of a possible 90.
- Istvan (t) 90 points of a possible 90.
This indicates that none of the current front runner candidates, based on current data, are even vaguely close to being openly supportive of the TNC Platform for 2016.
- The likely hood of corruption is very high in Trump and Clinton based on organizational coalition sizes that they have previously been connected to. Johnson is only moderately less risky in terms of possible corruption.
- The TNC is very much interested in driving a community approach to voting on and approving candidates as a body of the membership. Since that has not been done the TNC cannot endorse any candidate.
- Addressing Zoltan Istvan as a candidate for the Transhumanist Party. The TNC cannot endorse or support Zoltan on the basis of the aforementioned third point of this finding of fact. However the following items have been researched and are accurate.
- Zoltan Istvan is legitimately registered as a candidate for president of the United States.
- Zoltan Istvan created a legal entity to represent his party that is not in violation of the law given the amount of money and resource currently present in his organization.
- Zoltan has not done anything legally wrong around his campaign or in any way that we are aware of based on the evidence.
It is important to note that the executive committee has validated this information with the FEC and legal consultants. While his ‘party’ is not a legal 527 or organized at a state level given the resources involved Zoltan is legally within his rights currently.
As to how Zoltan has run his campaign or the perceptions of individuals in the community it is not for the TNC to judge given that we cannot endorse anyone w/o a public debate and party convention as per the TNC regulations.
References:
Nather, D. “Clinton vs. Trump: A race between a policy wonk and a ‘black box”, STAT, 2 Nov 2016 https://www.statnews.com/2016/06/13/donald-trump-hillary-clinton-medical-research/
The Gallup; “Extraordinary Impact through Analytics and Advice” private panel member study 2016 http://www.gallup.com/
TNC 2016 Convention; “Official TNC Platform” 2 NOV 2016 http://wiki.transhumanpolitics.com/index.php?title=Official_TNC_Platform
TNC 2016 Convention; “Legal Catagory Documents” 2 NOV 2016 http://wiki.transhumanpolitics.com/index.php?title=Category:Legal
Trump, D.; “issues” 2 NOV 2016 https://www.donaldjtrump.com/issues/
Trump, D.; “positions” 2 NOV 2016 https://www.donaldjtrump.com/positions
Clinton, H.; “Learn more about Hillary’s vision for America” 2 NOV 2016 https://www.hillaryclinton.com/issues/
Johnson, G.; “Issues” 2 NOV 2016 https://www.johnsonweld.com/issues
Wikipedia Foundation “Gary Johnson” 2 NOV 2016 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Johnson
Randal, W.; Carmine, D.; “The Dictator’s Handbook: A Practical Manual for the Aspiring Tyrant” ISBN 978-0615652429 (Gull Pond Books) http://dictatorshandbook.net/
Zoltan, I.; “Platform” 2 NOV 2016 http://www.transhumanistparty.org/Platform.html
Zoltan, I.; “FEC Form 2” 2 NOV 2016 FEC.gov http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg?_201509010300021171+0
Persiloy, N.; Cain, B.; “The Legal Status of Political Parties: A Reassessment of Competing Paradigms” Columbia Law School, 2 NOV 2016 http://www2.law.columbia.edu/instructionalservices/political_parties/per_cain.pdf
FEC “Party GUI”, 2 NOV 2016, reference 100.15.Party Definition and ballot control; http://www.fec.gov/pdf/partygui.pdf
November 5, 2016 at 12:15 pm
Nice to see that the TNC which came into being as a direct consequence of the controversy triggered by attacks from right wing religious “transhumanists” on Zoltan Istvan has now seen fit to award him the maximal possible score on meeting its platform choices.
November 7, 2016 at 8:37 pm
keep in mind this is only a map to our policy platform not his other choices. we are NOT endorsing him to be clear. further we did do the research to confirm the FEC stuff and as a transhumanist organization we must be fact based. the fact is he does support our platform. that does not mean we support his candidacy and there is a clear difference.
September 28, 2017 at 12:03 am
Flawed report – with little actual investigation into Zoltan’s activities.
Is it legal to pretend to be a Party ? And a candidate of this fake party?
I think not.
Is it legal to take money from foreign nationals? No.
Has Zoltan revealed his budget to the FEC? No.
This is almost as bad as the Warren Commission – disappointing
October 6, 2017 at 4:04 pm
to be clear the TNC report was factually vetted and is only commenting on the specific items listed. all investigation was into specific facts and sense the TNC was not going to endorse Zoltan the report was only informational and focused on the main candidates and the TNC platform.
As to legal to ‘pretend’ to be a party… strictly speaking, it is legal for anyone to declare they are a member of any party they makeup and run as that parties candidate and win. we have vetted that this is legal strictly speaking. just because we disagree with someone doesn’t make it illegal. The real issue with legality is when money becomes increasingly involved…
is it legal to take money from foreign nationals? not is it not but this is not a fact that was addressed by the report.
As to Zoltans budget, that again is not related to the key elements of the TNC report.
Remember there can be lots of problems with Zoltan’s process or his campaign or party but that was not the intent of the report as Zoltan is not related to the TNC nor a real candidate and therefore only included in the report as a side note that included some key facts that were vetted. see the attacked references and you can validate those facts ones self.